1.) South Island of New Zealand - awesome. Fiordland National Park, Christchurch, Arthur's Pass, no need to state more. Want to go back desperately.
2.) Kodiak Island - home to the most Grizzlies per capita
3.) Iceland - flown over it but never visited it.
4.) Vancouver Island, Canada! Can't wait, taking the RV to the island and roam at will in about five years once retire.
5.) Ni'ihau Island - just because you have to be invited to the "Forbidden Island"