Jump to content

Should AE change to ICAO codes?

* * * - - 2 votes

  • Please log in to reply
23 replies to this topic

Poll: Should AE switch to ICAO codes (28 member(s) have cast votes)

Should AE switch to ICAO codes

  1. Voted Yes, have just ICAO (3 votes [10.71%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 10.71%

  2. No, keep IATA (11 votes [39.29%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 39.29%

  3. Abolish airport codes altogether (0 votes [0.00%])

    Percentage of vote: 0.00%

  4. Have Both IATA and ICAO codes (14 votes [50.00%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 50.00%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1
Guest_Stan_*

Guest_Stan_*
  • Guests
ICAO codes unlock the possibility of a wider range of airports and heliports alike around the globe. :)

#2
Alfrenzo

Alfrenzo

    Probably retired

  • Member
  • 861 posts

User's Awards

2       6    3   
Does it makes sense to have ICAO codes solely?

I don't, but IATA and ICAO can go ogether like in gcmapper.

noelair%20banner.png


#3
Guest_Stan_*

Guest_Stan_*
  • Guests
thanks for your take alfrenzo

#4
Ioh

Ioh

    Baaauussss

  • Member
  • 1,649 posts
Can you add an option for both please, I wont vote otherwise.

ADWAM.png


#5
Alfrenzo

Alfrenzo

    Probably retired

  • Member
  • 861 posts

User's Awards

2       6    3   

Can you add an option for both please, I wont vote otherwise.


He's asking ICAO per se. What of that can you not understand?

noelair%20banner.png


#6
Obelix

Obelix

    Fetch me a Wild Boar Dogmatix

  • Member
  • 385 posts
IATA codes are used for for airline timetables and ICAO codes are used for flight planning, air traffic control, and weather reporting. If an airport doesn't have a IATA code it will most likely have little to no commercial traffic, and if there is it's most likely to be small scale domestic or charter traffic, and will not appear in any reservation system.

Posted Image
Not a real 737NG cockpit, only a SIM cockpit Posted Image


#7
n.x.w.m

n.x.w.m

    taiwanball

  • Data Collector
  • 2,061 posts

IATA codes are used for for airline timetables and ICAO codes are used for flight planning, air traffic control, and weather reporting. If an airport doesn't have a IATA code it will most likely have little to no commercial traffic, and if there is it's most likely to be small scale domestic or charter traffic, and will not appear in any reservation system.


Good point. ^_^

cUDPatH.jpg


#8
violetQueen

violetQueen

    The Resident B!tch

  • Member
  • 584 posts

IATA codes are used for for airline timetables and ICAO codes are used for flight planning, air traffic control, and weather reporting. If an airport doesn't have a IATA code it will most likely have little to no commercial traffic, and if there is it's most likely to be small scale domestic or charter traffic, and will not appear in any reservation system.


Agreed, AE should stick to IATA, of course unless the TS is willing to do all the work collecting the ICAO codes for every single airport themselves... :P


I liked TW and it's gone. NW, and it's gone. CO, and it's gone. Pray I don't like you.

"How sad it would be, should laughter disappear."
Posted Image

Spoiler


#9
Ioh

Ioh

    Baaauussss

  • Member
  • 1,649 posts
That is a good point, being a Data Collector myself I don't see why I should waste my time on this unnecessary thing :/

ADWAM.png


#10
Conor

Conor

    Angry Irishman

  • AE Moderator
  • 1,404 posts
I know more ICAO codes than IATA!

#11
Yuxi

Yuxi

    AE Developer

  • AE Developer
  • 4,365 posts
It doesn't have to be one or the other - in fact, we have both in the system - but being able to sort/filter by ICAO in addition to IATA codes would be a good addition. :P

#12
highland

highland

    AE Luver

  • Member
  • 393 posts
one simple airport filter is all i need. now why are you guy's now thinking about breaking it ? ?

#13
KJS607

KJS607

    The O.G. Savage

  • Member
  • 3,860 posts
  • Website:https://www.thetravelsavage.com/

User's Awards

6       3   

It doesn't have to be one or the other - in fact, we have both in the system - but being able to sort/filter by ICAO in addition to IATA codes would be a good addition. :P

Liking the idea :D

msg-1341-0-50048700-1680446869_thumb.png

 

I did a thing: thetravelsavage.com

 


#14
M4matthew

M4matthew

    M4Matthew

  • Member
  • 673 posts

I Would like the ability to search airport codes in capitals...and airport names in lowercase. :/ its a pain to type in "BOS" and get "Boston regional" :P


Yes! Yes! Yes!

#15
highland

highland

    AE Luver

  • Member
  • 393 posts

It doesn't have to be one or the other - in fact, we have both in the system - but being able to sort/filter by ICAO in addition to IATA codes would be a good addition. :P

no, no, no, no, no....
if theres going to be all this energy
burnt up working on something that would
be humongously helpfull. add the distance
or miles from to the arrival side of the
route management screen. or even trade out
the open slots inplace of distance.
really, i'm willing to bet that when it
comes down to it. more players then not
would rather have the distance added to
the arrival filter then to have to wonder
if their airpot has a weather station or not...

IATA ? ICAO ? who cares ? ?
do something good that let's me NOT have to
use a paper and pen ever time my airline get's
better then 50 routes......

please.

#16
txaggie

txaggie

    AE Know It All

  • Member
  • 157 posts

no, no, no, no, no....
if theres going to be all this energy
burnt up working on something that would
be humongously helpfull. add the distance
or miles from to the arrival side of the
route management screen. or even trade out
the open slots inplace of distance.
really, i'm willing to bet that when it
comes down to it. more players then not
would rather have the distance added to
the arrival filter then to have to wonder
if their airpot has a weather station or not...

IATA ? ICAO ? who cares ? ?
do something good that let's me NOT have to
use a paper and pen ever time my airline get's
better then 50 routes......

Haiku.



FIFY

#17
QK Flight Industries

QK Flight Industries

    a Wandering Guide to AE and Beyond

  • Member
  • 2,135 posts

I Would like the ability to search airport codes in capitals...and airport names in lowercase. :/ its a pain to type in "BOS" and get "Boston regional" :P


Let's take this a step further. Why can't there be a filter where by default it assumes that you are typing in an IATA code (LAX) unless you specify icao:klax or name:los angeles? Better yet, have a setting in the settings to specify which field you would use by default (IATA/ICAO/Name) and then use specifiers (iata:hnl / icao:phnl / name:honolulu) for the non default searches?

EDIT: I suppose the name specifier would be useless if the field would automatically assume name search with 5+ characters and no specifiers...

16590230781_7cc5cf6013.jpg

Sig.png

AXUbLwK.png

It's really me, now. #backtoAE


#18
Alfrenzo

Alfrenzo

    Probably retired

  • Member
  • 861 posts

User's Awards

2       6    3   

I Would like the ability to search airport codes in capitals...and airport names in lowercase. :/ its a pain to type in "BOS" and get "Boston regional" :P

:thumbup:

And, can you make it find the ones with most gates by default? :P It's irritating to get Angelborg-Helsingbwhatever when I try to find either Helsinki or Singapore <_<

noelair%20banner.png


#19
highland

highland

    AE Luver

  • Member
  • 393 posts
what is Haiku ?

and fify ? what the heck does fify mean ?

#20
ar157

ar157

    Resident Australian Arnimal

  • Member
  • 1,476 posts

User's Awards

     
can we make ae caps friendly coz seriously typing in JFK doesn't yield any results, unless this has been changed and i am unaware? :huh:




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users